What to Do If Your Public Defender Isn't Doing Their Job

If your public defender won't return calls or seems unprepared, you have options: talk to them, go to a supervisor, ask the court for a new lawyer, or file a complaint. Here's how it works in the US and Canada.

What to Do If Your Public Defender Isn't Doing Their Job

Short answer: Start by putting your concerns to your lawyer directly, in writing. If that doesn't work, go to their supervisor. If the relationship has truly broken down, you can ask the judge for a new lawyer, but courts only grant that for good reasons. Don't fire your lawyer or stop cooperating without a plan, because that can hurt your case.

Public defenders are usually overloaded, not lazy. Many carry far more cases than recommended. That's not your fault, and it doesn't take away your right to effective help.

Your rights

  • US: The Sixth Amendment guarantees the right to a lawyer in criminal cases, and Gideon v. Wainwright (1963) requires states to provide one if you can't afford it in felony cases (later extended to any case where you could go to jail). You're entitled to effective assistance, not a perfect lawyer or the lawyer of your choice.
  • Canada: There's no general right to free counsel in every case, but provinces fund legal aid for people who qualify financially and face serious charges. Courts can also order state-funded counsel when it's needed for a fair trial (a "Rowbotham" application).

Step 1: Talk to your lawyer, in writing

Write down your specific concerns:

  • "You haven't returned my calls since [date]."
  • "I haven't seen the evidence (disclosure/discovery) in my case."
  • "I gave you names of witnesses and I don't know if anyone contacted them."
  • "I want to understand the plea offer and my chances at trial."

Ask for a meeting. A written note creates a record and often gets a faster response. Many problems are about communication, not effort.

What's normal: Lawyers may not call back right away, may recommend a plea you don't like, or may decide not to file a motion they think will fail. Strategy decisions are mostly theirs to make. But some decisions are yours: whether to plead guilty, whether to testify, and (in the US) whether to have a jury trial.

Step 2: Go to a supervisor

Most public defender offices have supervising attorneys. In Canada, legal aid lawyers work either in a staff office (with a supervisor) or as private lawyers paid through a legal aid certificate. Contact the supervisor or the legal aid office, explain the problem briefly, and ask for help. Sometimes they'll reassign the case internally.

Step 3: Ask the court for a new lawyer

If the relationship has broken down completely, you can ask the judge to appoint a different lawyer.

  • California: This is called a Marsden motion, after People v. Marsden (1970). You tell the judge (usually without the prosecutor in the room) why your lawyer isn't representing you adequately, or why the conflict is so severe that it will lead to ineffective representation.
  • Other US states: Usually called a motion to substitute counsel or a request for new counsel. Judges look for a real conflict of interest, a complete breakdown in communication, or clear inadequate representation.
  • Canada: You can ask legal aid to transfer your certificate to a different lawyer. Legal aid plans allow changes only in limited circumstances, and changing lawyers more than once is difficult.

Courts don't grant new lawyers just because you disagree with advice, dislike your lawyer's personality, or want to delay the case. Bring specific, factual examples.

Step 4: File a complaint

If your lawyer acted unethically (for example, lied to you, missed deadlines without explanation, or had a conflict of interest), you can complain to the state bar (US) or provincial law society (Canada). A complaint won't change your current case quickly, but it creates a record and can lead to discipline.

After the case: ineffective assistance

If you're convicted and believe your lawyer's performance was seriously deficient, you may be able to raise ineffective assistance of counsel on appeal or in post-conviction proceedings. In the US, the test from Strickland v. Washington (1984) asks whether the lawyer's performance fell below an objective standard of reasonableness and whether that likely changed the outcome. Canada uses a similar two-part test. These claims are hard to win, which is why raising problems early matters.

Can you hire a private lawyer instead?

Yes, at any time if you can afford one. Some private lawyers will do a single consultation to give you a second opinion on your case. Your public defender should cooperate with a handover.

Sources

More in Criminal Law

All Criminal Law articles →