Short answer: In Canada and most US states, you can record a phone call you're part of without telling the other person. That's called one-party consent: your own consent is enough. But about a dozen US states, including California, Florida, Illinois, Pennsylvania and Washington, require everyone's consent. Recording a call you're not part of, without anyone's consent, is a crime almost everywhere.
When a call crosses borders, follow the stricter rule.
The two kinds of consent rules
- One-party consent: At least one person in the conversation agrees to the recording. If you're on the call, that can be you.
- All-party (two-party) consent: Everyone in the conversation must agree. Announcing "this call is being recorded" at the start, and the other person continuing, usually counts as consent.
United States
Federal law (the Wiretap Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2511(2)(d)) is one-party consent: you may record a call you're part of, as long as you aren't doing it to commit a crime or tort.
States can be stricter. States that generally require all-party consent to record calls include:
Connecticut requires all-party consent for phone calls under its civil law, and Oregon requires it for in-person conversations but not phone calls. Everywhere else is one-party consent.
Canada
Canada is one-party consent. Under section 184 of the Criminal Code, intercepting a private communication is a crime (up to five years in prison), but there's an exception when one of the people in the conversation consents. So you can record a call you're part of without telling the other person.
Two cautions:
- Businesses recording customer calls must follow privacy law, such as the federal PIPEDA, which generally requires telling customers and explaining why. That's why companies announce recordings.
- Using a recording can raise other issues, for example sharing it publicly in a way that's defamatory or harassing.
United Kingdom
Individuals can generally record their own phone calls for personal use without telling the other person. The rules under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 target interception by third parties, not participants. Problems can arise if you share a recording: publishing it may raise data protection, privacy or confidentiality issues. Businesses recording calls must comply with UK GDPR and telecoms regulations, which usually means telling callers.
Australia
Australia is the trickiest, because both federal and state laws apply:
- The federal Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 restricts intercepting calls as they pass over the network. Recording a call you're part of with a device on your own phone is generally not "interception."
- State surveillance devices laws decide whether you can record. Victoria, Queensland and the Northern Territory allow a party to record a private conversation without the other's consent. New South Wales, South Australia, Western Australia, Tasmania and the ACT generally require all parties' consent, with limited exceptions (such as protecting your lawful interests).
Can you use a recording as evidence?
- US: Recordings made legally are usually admissible. Illegal recordings in all-party states are often excluded, and making them can expose you to criminal charges and lawsuits.
- Canada: Legal one-party recordings are often used in court, including in family and employment cases, subject to the usual rules of evidence.
- Always talk to a lawyer before relying on a recording in a legal dispute.
Safe practice
- Know where everyone on the call is located.
- If anyone is in an all-party state or jurisdiction, announce the recording and get consent.
- Never record a conversation you're not part of.
- Store recordings securely and don't share them without thinking through privacy and defamation risks.
Sources